Are literary prizes generally indicators of quality?

3 reading minutes
written by Le Regard Libre · 21 April 2026 · 0 comment

At the start of each new literary season, book awards become a must for readers. Banners in the window, covers in the media, sales on the rise... But are these distinctions in principle a guarantee of quality?

Quentin Perissinotto

Book reviewer at Regard Libre

Yes. While the jurors of the major prizes are sometimes criticized for acting more out of co-optation than literary sensibility, the accusation cannot be generalized. Some juries are made up entirely of people from outside the literary world, who meet for the sole pleasure of discussing their reading affinities, often for the first time. This is the case for the Goncourt des lycéens, the Prix du public RTS, the Prix du roman Fnac and various publishing house readers' prizes (Le Livre de Poche or Points, to name but a few). In this case, a

This content is reserved for our subscribers.

If you have an account, please log in. Otherwise, discover our different subscription packages and create an account from CHF 2.50 for the first month.
Le Regard Libre
Le Regard Libre

Switzerland's first monthly debate magazine