Mr. Director of RTS, don't keep quiet about Islamism
rts extreme right islamism
Pascal Crittin, Director of RTS,
How can you let a guest make shocking and untrue statements without reacting? Today, Thursday, January 13, in the 12h45 from RTS, the guest on the show, Mr. Ugo Palheta, co-author of the book Facing the fascist threat, while elaborating on his points in response to a question about ’Islamophobia,« stated that France, through its military interventions «in Mali and Central African Republic» (he was likely referring to Burkina Faso in the latter case, since the Central African Republic is overwhelmingly Christian), helped create an image of Islam and Muslims as an «external enemy.».
This argument is false and dangerous. France is conducting military operations in the Sahel against jihadist organizations that commit atrocities and aim to establish Islamist regimes, something that a large portion of the local population does not want, either because they have already experienced such regimes or because they never want to have to.
It is important to note that the argument regarding French military interventions in Syria and Iraq is one (among others) used by the perpetrators of the November 13, 2015, attacks—whose alleged accomplices are currently on trial in Paris—to justify their actions. I am obviously not saying that Mr. Palheta does not condemn these acts, or that he is not as horrified by them as we all are—that would make no sense. What I take issue with is a line of reasoning that could suggest France provoked the crimes it suffered on its own territory. Yet this overlooks the hatred and resentment toward the West that Islamist ideology has fostered for many decades.
It is also important to note that, in the years leading up to the 2015 attacks in France, prominent figures in political Islam in France (some of whom were allied with La Manif pour tous, or even close to the anti-Semite Alain Soral), were calmly discussing the benefits of establishing a Salafist-style Islamist regime in Mali—a country that «had every right to pursue its own path.”».
Read also, by the same author Alain Soral—«far-right»—and that’s it?
The fact that Mr. Palheta, in his remarks on today’s 12:45 p.m. broadcast, failed to distinguish between Islam and Islamism, or between Muslims and Islamists, will come as no surprise to those (who are numerous and quite happy to live alongside Muslims in society) who are interested in these issues and who, for their part, make this crucial distinction between faith in God and a politico-religious ideology.
Mr. Palheta may be among those who believe that the fight against armed Islamism abroad or political Islamism in Europe or elsewhere is part of a neocolonial worldview, that Islamism is essentially just an expression of identity and activism among Muslims who—to come back to that point—have every right to do whatever they want with Islam (except kill, of course), given France’s colonial past, etc.
Please know, Mr. Director, that many Muslims—most of whom are progressive—have had enough of this vision that purports to be based on solidarity but is in reality rooted in a culture of victimhood, and that—whether they have experienced Islamism themselves, or have been subjected to it, or have lived alongside it, no longer want to hear that Islamist regimes can be good for Muslims in the name of a “differentialism” worthy of the reactionary New Right, or that French military interventions in the Sahel would create «Muslims»—the image of a «enemy from outside"».
We cannot, in the name of the necessary fight against the far right and the dangers it poses, give in to Islamism. To do so would be cowardly and would only fuel the rise of the far right. Anyone acting in good faith understands, moreover, that the Islamist attacks of 2015, 2016, and 2017 helped fuel support for the far right and strengthen a threatening ultra-right movement. That was, in fact, one of the goals of these terrorists: to sow chaos in our democracies.
So, please, Mr. Director, when confusing remarks like the ones made today are made on your show, it would be good, at the very least, to respond with a question. You cannot report on and condemn the Taliban regime in Afghanistan as you do, and then fail to react when someone claims that French military interventions in the Sahel are helping to shape the image of the «Muslim»as «external enemy». The Democrats' line is clear: neither extreme right, nor Islamism.
Yours sincerely,
Antoine Menusier
Antoine Menusier is a journalist. Editor-in-chief of the Bondy Blog from 2009 to 2011 and a former senior reporter at Time and L'Hebdo, he is the author of Livre des indésirés - A history of Arabs in France (Editions du Cerf, 2019). Today, he writes for the Swiss media outlet Watson and contributes to the French magazines Marianne and L'Express.
RTS responded to this letter on January 14 on the Facebook group «Le petit journal des médias suisses»:
Hello Antoine Menusier,
Ugo Palheta's comments are his alone, as is your interpretation of them. In this case, his response was generally concerned with the instrumentalization of Islam by the extreme right, which he claims to discern in the growing Islamophobia in Europe. The question of France's military interventions in Africa, which is the central subject of your message, was only briefly mentioned in Mr. Palheta's reply.
The issue you raise - which is just as interesting - concerns the instrumentalization of Islam by Islamist and extremist groups. It deserves just as much attention, as you rightly point out. However, in order to respect the angle chosen for this discussion and to ensure clarity in view of its relatively short format, the editorial team considers it preferable to distinguish these different issues and deal with them separately.
Kind regards,
Marc Allgöwer, Deputy Editor-in-Chief RTS TV
Leave a comment